Document forgery at the University of Tübingen?

By Thomas Ziegner

Tübingen. Uncovering coun­ter­feits is not only the task of the press, but also of sci­ence, to which one may, with some good will, count the disci­pli­ne of gene­ral rhe­to­ric cul­ti­va­ted in Tübingen. But now it seems that the semi­nar for gene­ral rhe­to­ric, once hea­ded by Walter Jens, is guil­ty of for­gery. His first pri­ze for the „Speech of the Year“, award­ed in 1998 to Martin Walser by for­mer chief rhe­to­ri­ci­an Gert Ueding in order to bene­fit vam­pi­resk from the publi­ci­ty of the Bubis-Walser con­tro­ver­sy, is still shown on the seminar’s cur­rent web­site as cor­rect­ly.

Although the hono­rable sci­en­tists know that the­re was no jury at that time, they pro­vi­de their good names for the hoax, the­re was one. Is this now docu­ment for­gery? Or just the usu­al cor­rup­ti­on in the com­pa­ny? And would the guards have to inter­fe­re with the obser­van­ce of sci­en­ti­fic prin­ci­ples — the uni­ver­si­ty has an IZEW, an International Center for Ethics in the Sciences — inter­ve­ne or is it not so accu­ra­te with the rhe­to­ri­ci­ans anyway?

Maybe we know more next year. Now the rhe­to­ri­ci­ans are busy: Soon they will have cho­sen the „Speech of the Year 2017“.

Addition on 18.12., 1:30 pm: They mana­ged to find a win­ner just an hour ago: Peter Strohschneider, President of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. Among other things, they prai­se his „intellec­tu­al honesty“.